At 7.17 percent — the highest weekly average since January 2025 — the most valuable conversation in any Boston transaction is no longer about price. It is about the buyer's monthly payment, and there are two separate levers that move it.
Most people only know about one.
The three structures
Permanent buydown (discount points). Money paid at closing to lower the rate for the life of the loan. Roughly, one point costs one percent of the loan amount and buys down the rate by some fraction of a percent — the exact ratio varies by lender and day.
Temporary buydown (2-1 or 3-2-1). Funds go into an escrow account that subsidizes the payment for the first years. On a 2-1, the buyer pays as though the rate were two points lower in year one and one point lower in year two, then the full note rate from year three. The rate on the note never actually changes.
General seller concession. A credit toward closing costs and prepaids. Useful, but it does nothing to the monthly payment, which is why it is the weakest of the three right now.
Why the buydown beats a price cut, in numbers
Take a $625,000 Boston condo, 20 percent down, $500,000 loan.
Option A — $25,000 price reduction. Loan drops to $480,000. Monthly principal and interest falls by about $135.
Option B — $25,000 as a permanent rate buydown. Depending on lender and structure, that can commonly buy roughly a full point. On $500,000, a full point is worth about $330 a month.
Same cost to the seller. Roughly two and a half times the effect on what the buyer qualifies against.
That gap is the entire argument, and it exists because the buyer's constraint is a payment ceiling, not a purchase price.
Which structure for which situation
Permanent buydown — buyer staying long. Ask your loan officer for the break-even in months: cost of points divided by monthly savings. Break-even of 54 months against a twelve-year hold is a clear win. Break-even of 54 months against a four-year hold is not.
Temporary buydown — income is rising, or you genuinely expect to refinance. Careful with the second reason. Refinance activity is currently at its slowest pace since February 2025, and everyone doing those refinances once assumed rates would fall. A 2-1 that depends on refinancing in year three is a bet, not a plan. Underwriting generally qualifies the buyer at the full note rate anyway, which is a good discipline — if you cannot qualify at the real rate, the buydown is hiding a problem rather than solving one.
Straight concession — when the obstacle is cash to close rather than monthly payment. Different problem, different tool.
The caps nobody checks until it is too late
Lenders limit seller contributions by loan type and down payment. The ceiling varies meaningfully across conventional, FHA, and VA, and by how much the buyer is putting down.
Confirm the cap before structuring the offer. A negotiated concession that exceeds the allowable limit gets cut at underwriting, and then the deal is being renegotiated three weeks before closing with a buyer who has already moved on emotionally.
Two more:
It still has to appraise. A buydown does nothing about a contract price the property will not support.
It has to be in the contract. Concessions are negotiated terms, not handshakes, and in Massachusetts a signed and accepted Offer to Purchase has been treated as a binding contract — which means the structure needs to be right in that document, not sorted out later in the purchase and sale.
Why sellers should prefer it to a price cut
Beyond the arithmetic, there is a market-signaling advantage.
A price reduction is public and permanent. It resets your list price, appears in every portal's history, is visible to every buyer and every buyer's agent, and invites the next round of negotiation. Buyers who see one reduction wait for the second.
A concession is negotiated once, with one buyer, inside a specific offer. The market never sees it. Your list price holds, your days-on-market story stays intact, and you have moved the only number the buyer was actually solving for.
In a market where inventory climbed 5.4 percent in August year over year and contracts signed fell 4.7 percent, protecting the integrity of your list price while still closing the deal is worth real money.
Why buyers should ask, and will probably get it
With applications down three straight weeks and ARM share up to nearly 10 percent, sellers know the buyer pool is thinner and more payment-sensitive than it was.
A seller who will refuse a $25,000 price cut will frequently agree to $25,000 in concessions, because the two feel completely different to them even though they cost the same.
Ask for it explicitly in the offer, with the structure specified — permanent buydown, temporary buydown, or closing cost credit — rather than as a vague credit your lender then has to figure out how to apply.
The five questions
- What is the allowable seller contribution cap for my loan type and down payment?
- What does one point cost on my loan, and how much rate does it buy today?
- What is my break-even in months on a permanent buydown?
- If temporary, what rate am I being qualified at, and what does the payment become in year three?
- Is the structure written into the offer, or are we planning to sort it out later?
That last one is where these fall apart.
Whichever side you are on, send me the deal and I will model the price-cut and buydown versions side by side so you can see which one actually moves the number.
Chris Remmes, Managing Broker, Remmes & Co. [email protected] | 617-398-0015


