Let me make the case against properly, because it deserves a real hearing and most people who repeat it cannot explain why.
Six real problems
1. Tenant protections are strong and the process is slow. A valid lease survives the sale — you buy a building and step into the landlord position on existing terms, and a sale is not grounds to terminate a tenancy. For a tenancy at will you need written notice of at least thirty days or one full rental period, whichever is longer. If the tenant does not leave voluntarily, removal runs through summary process in housing court, and nobody underwrites a building on the assumption a court calendar will cooperate with their renovation schedule.
2. Security deposits are a liability trap. Massachusetts deposit rules are unforgiving, and mishandled deposits create liability that follows the building. This blows up more deals at the eleventh hour than inspection findings do. If deposits were never held in a separate account, or interest was never paid, that is the seller's problem until the moment it becomes yours.
3. Lead paint, with teeth. Any pre-1978 property is assumed to contain lead paint unless proven otherwise. If a child under six will live in the unit, the owner must have it deleaded or brought into Interim Control within 90 days of taking title, and Massachusetts imposes strict liability when a child under six is harmed by lead hazards.
And the part people do not expect: you cannot refuse to rent to families with children under six. That is housing discrimination carrying fines, lawsuits, and potential criminal penalties. You also cannot ask a tenant to waive their lead rights, and tenant notification applies to every tenant of a pre-1978 home whether or not they have a young child.
4. The entire city turns over on one day. Something close to two thirds of Boston leases end on August 31. Your vacancy risk is not spread across the year — it is concentrated into one week, and missing that window can mean carrying a vacant unit for months, because the next natural turnover is twelve months away.
5. The expenses are heavier than the pro forma says. Insurance premiums on older masonry buildings have risen sharply, and with active knob and tube some carriers will not write the property at all. In many Boston triple-deckers the units are not separately metered, so the owner pays water and sewer and tenants have no incentive to care. Whether units are separately heated is one of the largest operating variables in this stock. And the capital is real: roofs, rear porches — frequently the most expensive component on a triple-decker — heating systems, electrical service.
6. The yield is thin. Gross yields in the inner neighborhoods run in the neighborhood of five percent. After taxes, insurance, utilities, management, maintenance, vacancy, and an honest capital reserve line, net cash yields commonly compress to the low single digits unless you buy well or create value.
That is a real case. If you want current cash flow, there are American markets that will give you considerably more of it with a fraction of the regulatory overhead, and I would not try to talk you out of them.
Now the other side
Tenant quality and the vacancy profile are genuinely different.
Consider who arrives. Tens of thousands of people land here every September, skewed toward graduate students, medical residents, fellows, postdocs, and new hires at hospitals, labs, universities, and biotechs. Employed, credentialed, income-verifiable people, frequently with institutional affiliations, in a metro whose employment base is physically embedded and not relocating.
Low vacancy, strong applicant pools, and renewal demand that does not depend on one employer staying in town. That never appears in a yield calculation.
The September 1 cycle is a tool as well as a constraint.
Your vacancy risk is concentrated — and entirely predictable, twelve months in advance, every year. You know exactly when your leases end. You can plan capital work around it, schedule turnovers, stage a sale around it, and deliver a unit vacant on a natural expiration instead of paying for it.
Landlords hurt by September 1 are the ones who did not plan twelve months out. Landlords who use it are the ones who did.
The supply constraint does the work that cash flow does not.
Nobody is building more 1910 triple-deckers. The lots are built, demolition triggers Article 85 review for all buildings at least 50 years of age — nearly everything here — and any project needing zoning relief means a formal refusal, an appeal within 45 days, a hearing 60 to 90 days out, every abutter notified, and three to twelve months or more with no guaranteed yes.
So what you own cannot easily be replicated by a competitor, in a region with an annual arriving cohort and an embedded employment base. That is the actual return, and it shows up as appreciation and amortization rather than monthly cash.
The regulatory overhead is a filter, not just a cost. Every problem on my list is a reason somebody else will not buy the building. Investors unwilling to learn lead compliance, deposit handling, or housing court are investors not bidding against you. The friction is the moat.
The structural choice
Owner occupancy. Buy a two-, three-, or four-unit building, live in one unit, rent the others. It converts nearly every disadvantage above, and it is available to you once per property.
You are buying a primary residence, not an investment. That is the hinge. Low-down-payment loan products, better rates, and eligibility for state and municipal down payment assistance. An investor buying the identical building next door needs a substantially larger down payment at a worse rate. That single distinction is the largest financial advantage in this market.
The residential exemption, which almost never appears in a pro forma. It applies to your principal residence, and living in one unit of a multifamily qualifies you on the building. For FY2026 Boston's removed up to $351,108 of assessed value, saving qualifying owners up to $4,353.74.
The absentee owner of the identical building across the street gets none of it. You collect rent on two units and pay a tax bill roughly four thousand dollars a year lower than your direct competition — about thirty thousand dollars over a seven-year hold, existing purely because you live there. Somerville's was worth about $4,578 this year, Cambridge's $3,403, Everett's $2,582.70. Not automatic: you file, and the deadline is April 1.
The assistance programs reach this inventory. The purchase price cap, reported at $675,000, reaches almost nothing in most of this region — but it still reaches real multifamily inventory in parts of Dorchester, Hyde Park, and Mattapan, and just outside the city in Everett, Revere, Chelsea, and Malden.
And the thin-yield problem partially dissolves, because you are not solving for yield. You are solving for your own housing cost. Two units producing income against a mortgage you were paying anyway is a different calculation, and the number you personally carry can land below what the same money buys as a one-bedroom condo in a more fashionable neighborhood.
Two honest cautions
Being a landlord is a job. Screening, repairs at inconvenient hours, deposit handling done correctly. If you do not want that job, do not do this — the numbers only work if you do the work.
You inherit the rent roll. A valid lease survives the sale, so if rents are twenty percent below market because the previous owner was good to long-term tenants, those are your rents until expiration, and the cycle ends August 31.
The answer
Absentee investor underwriting current cash flow: a hard market, and there are easier ones.
Owner-occupant with a long horizon: one of the better structural setups in the country, because the friction keeping your competition out does not apply to you the same way, and the supply constraint works for you every year you hold.
Send me your budget and I will run the owner-occupancy structure against real multifamily inventory, with the exemption and the assistance in the math rather than left out of it.
Chris Remmes, Managing Broker, Remmes & Co. [email protected] | 617-398-0015

