Most content about Boston multifamily investing is written to produce a phone call. Here is the version with the unflattering parts left in.
Start with the gross yield, then stop trusting it
Take the numbers that get quoted. Average apartment rents earlier this year ran around $4,249 a month in South Boston and $3,943 in the South End. Against a South Boston neighborhood median near $1.06 million, that works out to roughly a 4.8 percent gross yield.
Gross yield is annual rent divided by price. It is the number in every pitch and it is nearly meaningless, because it describes revenue before anything that consumes revenue.
After taxes, insurance, utilities, condo fees where applicable, management, maintenance, and vacancy, net cash yields in these neighborhoods commonly compress to the low single digits unless you buy well or create value. Industry surveys place stabilized infill cap rates in Boston in the low-to-mid single digits, which is the same story told from the institutional side.
That is the honest headline. Boston small multifamily is not a cash-flow market. It is an appreciation-and-amortization market with thin current income, and anyone selling it to you as cash flow is either not running the numbers or not showing you all of them.
The expenses that get left out of pro formas
Taxes, and their trajectory. Not just the current bill. Confirm the assessed value and understand that it resets, and that an absentee owner does not get the residential exemption an owner-occupant does.
Insurance. Premiums on older masonry buildings have risen sharply. And if there is active knob and tube wiring, some carriers will not write the property at all, which is a financing problem before it is a cost problem.
Water and sewer. In a lot of Boston triple-deckers the units are not separately metered, which means the owner pays, and tenants have no incentive to care.
Heat. Whether units are separately heated is one of the largest operating variables in this housing stock. A building where the owner heats three units is a materially different asset from one where tenants do.
Capital, amortized. Roof. Porches — rear porches on a triple-decker are frequently the most expensive component on the building. Heating systems. Electrical service. These are not maintenance; they are periodic large numbers, and a pro forma without a capital reserve line is a pro forma designed to look good.
Vacancy and turnover. Two units producing income eleven months a year is not two units producing income twelve months a year. And in this city turnover clusters, because leases run on the September 1 cycle.
Management. Whether you pay someone or do it yourself, it is a cost. If you do it yourself, you are working for the difference, and you should know your hourly rate.
The three things that actually make Boston multifamily work
One: owner occupancy. This is the largest single advantage available, and it is available once per property.
Live in one unit of a two-to-four-unit building and you are buying a primary residence, not an investment. That means low-down-payment loan products, better rates, and eligibility for the state and municipal assistance programs. An investor buying the identical building next door needs a substantially larger down payment at a worse rate.
Then add the residential exemption, which almost never appears in a pro forma. Boston's FY2026 exemption removed up to $351,108 of assessed value, saving qualifying owner-occupants up to $4,353.74. The absentee owner across the street gets none of it.
So you collect rent on two units and pay a tax bill roughly four thousand dollars lower than your competition. Over a seven-year hold that is thirty thousand dollars existing purely because you live there. Somerville's exemption was worth about $4,578, Cambridge's $3,403, Everett's $2,582.70 — same logic, different math.
Two: buying where the price-per-square-foot gap is real. Dorchester runs around $516 per square foot against a citywide figure near $675 and above $1,100 in Beacon Hill and the Seaport. A whole triple-decker near Savin Hill or Ashmont still trades somewhere in the $900,000 to $1.4 million range. Those numbers do not exist in Jamaica Plain, Somerville, or Charlestown.
Three: value creation rather than value purchase. Below-market rents you can bring to market as leases expire. A unit you can legally add or improve. A building where deferred capital is priced in and you do the work. Buying a stabilized building at market rents and market price produces the low single digits described above.
The legal and regulatory costs people underwrite at zero
Lead. Any pre-1978 property is assumed to contain lead paint unless proven otherwise. If a child under six lives in the unit, the owner must have it deleaded or brought into Interim Control. You cannot refuse to rent to families with children under six — that is housing discrimination with fines, lawsuits, and potential criminal penalties attached. Deleading runs from a few thousand for targeted component work to well over $10,000 for a full unit, against a state credit of up to $3,000 for full compliance.
Inherited leases. A valid lease survives the sale. You step into the landlord position on existing terms, and if rents are twenty percent below market because the seller was good to long-term tenants, those are your rents until expiration.
Security deposits. Massachusetts deposit rules are unforgiving, and mishandled deposits create liability that follows the building. Get the accounting — which bank, whose name, interest paid — before closing.
Legal use versus physical use. A third unit in the basement that was never permitted is a financing problem for you and for your eventual buyer.
What to actually ask for before you offer
- Actual collected rent roll, not asking rents, with lease expiration dates
- Two years of operating expenses with receipts, not estimates
- Utility bills and confirmation of what is separately metered
- Security deposit accounting and estoppel certificates from each tenant
- Roof, porch, heating, and electrical service age and condition
- Lead compliance status and any Letter of Compliance or Interim Control
- Permit history compared against physical use
- An insurance quote, early, especially if there is any knob and tube
The current environment
The 30-year fixed averaged 7.32 percent as of October 22 against 6.19 percent a year earlier. Debt is the primary input to a leveraged return, so that move compressed the math on every acquisition.
It also thinned the competition. Inventory has been building and contract volume falling, so you are negotiating against fewer people than you were a year ago — and a seller-paid rate buydown is more obtainable in this environment than it has been in years. At these rates, a point of rate is worth more to your return than a point of price.
The honest summary: this is a long-hold, appreciation-led, owner-occupancy-advantaged market with thin current yield and meaningful regulatory overhead. It has made a great many people in this city wealthy over twenty and thirty years. It has made very few people wealthy in three.
Send me a building you are looking at and I will run the real numbers — collected rents, honest expenses, a capital line, and the owner-occupancy comparison if it applies. If the deal does not work, I will tell you that, which is most of why people come back.
Chris Remmes, Managing Broker, Remmes & Co. [email protected] | 617-398-0015
Rent and yield figures per RentCafe and market data, early-to-mid 2026, and vary by sample. Rate per Freddie Mac PMMS, week ending October 22, 2026. Exemption figures per the respective assessors, FY2026. Lead Law per Massachusetts DPH. Not investment, legal, or tax advice.


